Zinga's blog

Zinga's Blog

Plantation Shutters vs Blinds: Which Is the Right Choice?

Window treatments like plantation shutters and blinds add some glamor to your home while protecting against ultraviolet (UV) rays from the Indianapolis summer sun. However, they both have distinct features, making the selection process difficult.

We’ve put together this plantation shutters vs. blinds article to give you a quick overview of both window treatments. You’ll learn the key differences between them, as well as the pros and cons of each type.

The Key Differences Between Plantation Shutters and Blinds

Plantation shutters and blinds differ in structure and mode of installation. Shutters are solid and permanently fixed to the sides of windows with metal fittings. Blinds are more flexible and are typically only fixed to the top of the window.

Style Options

Blinds offer more style choices overall because they come in many patterns and colors. Material options include fabric, metal, wood, and more. With the flexibility in styles, it’s easier to find the perfect blind for your interior décor regardless of your preferences.

There are fewer styles of plantation shutters to choose from, including:

Due to their tremendous versatility, you’re sure to find a matching option for your home. The elegant look of plantation shutters keeps them in style forever.

Overall Durability

Plantation shutters are more durable than even the best quality blinds. Most of them feature hard-wearing materials. Their secure position around or within your window recess makes them more difficult to damage while operating.

On the other hand, it’s common for blinds to fall off their position from everyday use. The higher-end options are durable and far less likely to break, but they typically won’t last as long as plantation shutters.

Maintenance Difficulty

Ease of maintenance is a significant talking point in the plantation shutters vs. blinds debate.

Keeping your blinds clean is tricky. Standard fabric blinds can’t go in the washing machine, so you have to wash off dirt and dust by hand.

Plantation shutters (and indeed wooden blinds) are easier to maintain because you can wipe down the shutter panels like any other wooden surface around your home.

The Pros and Cons of Plantation Shutters


  • Plantation shutters last longer overall
  • The unique structure adds value to your home
  • They are child safe because there are no built-in control cords or chains
  • Plantation shutter materials are hard-wearing
  • They are very low-maintenance units
  • They provide excellent insulation, which can significantly lower your energy bills
  • You can choose between wood, faux wood, and vinyl options
  • Compartmentalized control of the shutter sections simplifies light and ventilation management


  • Plantation shutters cost more than blinds
  • They fit on the window frame instead of the recess
  • Plantation shutters are heavy, so they may not suit certain window styles
  • You can’t raise plantation shutters completely
  • Changing installed plantation shutters is difficult

The Pros and Cons of Blinds


  • There are many design styles to choose from, so they fit in every interior décor theme
  • The available selection of materials to choose from allows you to pick the best fit for any environment
  • Blinds are very affordable
  • They offer a subtler aesthetic appeal compared to plantation shutters
  • They provide flexibility in controlling the levels of light and shade
  • Thicker and higher-quality blinds can improve your home’s energy efficiency
  • They are easier to change and install
  • You can raise blinds completely


  • Blinds are less durable than plantation shutters
  • They require more cleaning and maintenance
  • Fabric blinds can fade quickly with exposure to UV rays or moisture
  • You have to replace them more frequently due to their shorter lifespan
  • They are prone to damage from children and pets

Plantation Shutters vs Blinds: Which Should You Choose?

There is no right or wrong choice between plantation shutters and blinds. Both types of window treatments can fit in almost any interior décor. Therefore, the right choice will always remain subjective.

Let Us Help You Decide

We hope you’ve learned from our plantation shutters vs blinds debate and settled on one side of the divide. However, if you still need help, the professionals at Zinga’s can analyze your preferences and help you come to a decision. We’ve guided many homeowners in the Indianapolis area to the right choice, and we can do the same for you. Call (844) 494-6427 today to book an appointment.